Inside Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet’s Cozy NYC Dinner Date: ‘They Seemed So in Love’

Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet’s relationship is only getting stronger!

The couple were spotted having an intimate dinner date at Little Charli’s restaurant in New York City on Oct. 12, and according to an insider, Jenner and Chalamet showed off plenty of sweet PDA as they enjoyed some Italian food together.

“Kylie and Timothée were very cuddly and very cute,” the source tells PEOPLE exclusively. “They looked very much in love.”

As for what the pair chose off the menu: “They ordered standard meatballs.”

Deuxmoi was first to report on their low-key date night, during which the makeup mogul and actor were sitting across from one another as they chatted at the restaurant, according to a photo. Chalamet, who is in Manhattan filming the movie Marty Supreme, sported a casual hoodie while Jenner wore a simple white tee and black pants.

Another clip was also posted by 21 Met Gala on X (formerly Twitter) showing the two leaning toward each other in deep conversation.

Earlier in October, a source told PEOPLE that Jenner and Chalamet are “just a great couple” and “everyone loves them together.”

“He’s close with her family and she’s close with his family,” the insider continued. “It’s very serious, but also a fun relationship.”

“They’ve really been able to figure out a good balance between working and spending quality time together,” the source added.

The two were first linked in April 2023 but did not make their public debut until they attended Beyoncé’s Renaissance World Tour in September 2023. They then were seen at New York Fashion Week and the 2023 US Open together days later.

Although they have kept most of their relationship private, they had public date nights at the WSJ. Magazine Innovators Awards in November 2023 and the 2024 Golden Globes in January. The Wonka actor also joined The Kardashians star on her 27th birthday trip to the Bahamas in August.

A source later told PEOPLE, “She’s incredibly happy with him. She’s never been in love like this before,” adding, “He’s great for her.”

“He’s so discreet and always has her back,” the source noted. “He’s very much a gentleman and everything that Kylie deserves. They are very serious.”